i broke up with carter in september. by october i was dating tom. seven months later, im in love with tom, but still in love with carter.
this wasn't the plan. the plan was to date different guys, have fun and never have anything serious. the plan was to bide my time until i could be with carter for real. of course, real life was completely different. carter met someone and started dating her. i hate her for this. i don't even know her, and i hate that she could make him happy in a way i never could- she could be there everyday for things i always missed. i hate thinking he could love her more, that she could be prettier/smarter/funnier/better than me. but somehow, it was okay if i felt like that about tom. if i loved tom more, if i thought he was better for me.
i guess it would be easier if they were completely different, if i could point at one and know that he was the best fit for me and the person i'd love to marry. instead, i fell for two similar yet very different guys, and i can't choose one. how do you choose between the person who helped you grow up and get through all the drama of graduating and going to college and the person who helped you become an adult who could handle the hardest semester of college and pass it all with flying colors? how do you choose between the sexy mysterious dark-haired boy and the charming, outspoken who could be my twin in looks? what do you do when a trait you loved in one is present in the other? when they both hate ketchup, love flogging molly, bleed school spirit, are the most intelligent boys i've ever talked to, know all my moods and how to make me happy.
why do i have to make this decision? i wish i could have a father to decide my marriage for me, or a duel between the two just so i wouldn't have to deal with the pain of breaking my heart while breaking someone else's. i want one of them to decide for me. i want to be completely happy and in love with whoever i'm with and i want them to be completely happy and in love with me. i know that only one of them can do that now, but is it wrong to date him and always wait for the other? WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH ME? did i screw up the best thing i ever had only to find something better? is ending what i have now and never knowing what could be the wisest choice? is going back to someone it never really worked with a good idea?
am i really just too scared of being alone? part of me worries that tom will break up with me someday and that carter wont be there anymore and i'll be alone. the other part worries that i'll break up with one for the other, and it won't work and i'll have destroyed an amazing thing all on my own and i'll have to live with that. where did the confident girl that i used to be go? was i only like that because in the back of my mind i'd always thought carter would be the one to catch me when i needed him to?
i want to tell them both everything, but there's too much that could hurt them both. i've given both of them every part of me, and i'm scared i won't get all of myself back. i can be happy with them both, but i can't bear to lie to either one of them. i can't stand watching tom fall more in love with me knowing that part of me still loves a boy who may not love me back. i feel like such a whore- more than i ever have, including when i physically cheated on a boyfriend.
i need to make this decision soon before someone gets hurt even worse, but how can i? i've lost track of what i want and need in the sight of what they need, what my parents think is best, who my friends like better, and how desperately i want both of their families to like me. i can't decide who is best because i'll be shutting a door on the other, and i can't bear to leave myself open to being left all alone.
Carter:
Pros:
- knows me better than i know myself most of the time
- i know him better than anyone, or at least i did before his new girlfriend
- it's familiar, safe and comfortable
- my parents love him, he likes them, and i love his family and know they like me too
- he knows what he wants in life and will work to get those goals
- can provide for me if we do get married
- all our inside jokes, nicknames, stupid traditions and memories. all my jewelry that i love is from him.
- put up with me through all of the drama i had, and stayed with me even though i cheated.
Cons:
- DISTANCE.
- both of us have dreams that we dont want to sacrifice to be together.
- i can't forgive him for not telling me he slept with his girlfriend right away.
- he can't forgive me for cheating on him, and breaking up with him.
- we have completely separate lives now.
- different ideas on being a Christian, and neither one of us wants to change.
Tom:
Pros:
- he is close by and i can see him everyday
- i know exactly what he'd be like to live with
- we compliment eachother in ways i cant even name
- he treats me like i'm the most precious thing he's ever had.
- we have similiar ideas about where we want to end up
- he can provide for me very well when he's out of school
- he gets how i feel about religion
- hes seen the worst i have, and doesn't care.
- the physical attraction is insane- i've never had anything like it.
Cons:
- Our tempers are so different that it's hard for us to get through a problem
- i still don't think his brother/roommates approve of me, and it makes me want to stay away from them, leading him to spend more time away from them
- he's so laid back it sometimes seems that he doesn't care about me
- i'm too much of a flirt/party girl for him sometimes
that didn't help me at all. way to go. ive told tom a lot of this, and carter has heard a lot of it too but both of them are choosing to tell me they want to see me happy, and that it's the most important thing to them. one of them told me to not hurt the other one for him, because he wasn't worth it. damn it, that's not what i want. i want someone to fight for me, to say that he wants to be with me more than anything, and that i belong to him. i want someone to make me feel needed and like i am the only person they can see themselves with. only one guy can do that right now, but he still hasnt come right out and said it. I WANT TO BE PURSUED. more than anything, i want one guy who will do everything and anything to be with me. i need that. because i'm waiting to do that for a guy who's willing to do that for me.
i think i just need to be told im a bitch, and then told to get over myself. and then i just want one of these guys to decide for me.